Love Me, Love Me Not
An article written by Halbert Katzen
One bright morning in the middle of the night
Two dead boys got up to fight
Back to back, they faced each other
Drew their swords and began to fire
A deaf policeman heard the noise
And came to arrest the two dead boys
If you don't believe this lie is true
Go ask the blind man, he saw it, too
Author Unknown
A friend at summer camp taught me this poem when I was eleven.
And it has always stuck with me. This was the first time that
my eleven-year-old mind came to appreciate the concept of self-contradiction.
I've enjoyed word games ever since. Like the ever-curious oxymora,
most of which are benign and humorous. Found missing. Jumbo shrimp.
Clearly misunderstood. But there is one oxymoron that has me a
bit concerned: self-love.
Self-love has taken on a new meaning, a positive connotation,
that contradicts is traditional definition. My Random House Dictionary
defines love and self-love. Love has twenty-eight definitions,
all with the object of love outside one's self. There are just
three definitions of self-love and it's not a pretty sight: "excessive
regard for one's self," "conceit, vanity," "narcissism."
Has Random House lost touch with the times or have we inadvertently
lost sight of an important distinction in an effort to restore
health and wellbeing? To be sure, people are currently doing many
wonderful things in the name of self-love. The contemporary twist
on self-love inspires people to have a positive self-image, to
eat right, and to exercise. As well, it has encouraged people
to find the strength they need to get out of codependent, abusive
relationships.
"You have to be able to love yourself if you're going to be able
to love others." On the surface it sounds good. But there's a
danger in forsaking the negative connotation that self-love traditionally
has held. We can't spin the connotation of self-love 180( without
it effecting the value of what it means to love others. Said Socrates,
"The beginning of wisdom is the definition of terms." The contemporary
twist on self-love not only creates an oxymoron, but also a dangerous
one, because it goes unrecognized for its self-contradictory character.
All the positive things that are being done in the name of self-love
can be accomplished just as well, even better, if done in the
name of self-respect and self-worth. The noble nature of love
depends on placing the object of love outside of ourselves. By
standing firm on this position we are no less effective in working
to restore self-respect and self-worth when it is lost. In fact,
we can be even more effective because one way of loving others
is to embody these qualities, to be a positive role model for
others.
Nothing restores self-respect like a healthy appreciation of
the love one has for other people. What is it then that has precipitated
the ironic development of a positive, yet oxymoronic, definition
of self-love? The answer is twofold. First, we have been desperately
trying to break the cycle of abusive co-dependant relationships.
Second, we have witnessed the destructive behaviors that develop
with a breakdown of community consciousness and the loss of a
healthy sense of identity.
With abusive co-dependant relationships sometimes the stakes
are as high as life itself. Those who suffer abuse in co-dependant
relationships often feel unworthy of love and cater to a domineering
partner. In reaction to such situations, the term self-love is
often used as a foundation for the construction of healthy boundaries.
Establishing healthy boundaries is, of course, essential for stopping
the pattern of abusive relationships.
Developing appreciation for the difference between turning the
other cheek and participating in the perpetuation of bad behavior
is the crucial issue. This distinction adequately provides for
the restoration of self-respect, while preserving the value of
loving those who are abusive. Those caught up in abusive relationships
need to find wiser ways of loving their partners.
Complete disassociation may at times be an appropriate boundary
and may be considered an act of love that simultaneously restores
self-respect and a sense of self-worth. One of the difficulties
in ending abusive relationships is that feelings of love exist
for the abusive partner. Developing a self-interested mentality
can be very difficult for the abused partner. When we speak for
healthy boundaries in terms of how this loves the abuser, we work
with the value of loving others. This approach ends the cycle
of abuse, restores self-respect, and preserves the traditional
definition of self-love.
The reinvention of self-love as an expression of self-respect
and self-worth has also become a tool to re-establish a sense
of community identity. Woody Allen expressed the acme of self-deprecation
by stating "I would never wanna belong to any club that would
have someone like me for a member." To combat a growing sense
of spiritual isolation and disconnection from society we have
started to speak in terms of loving ourselves.
The longing for a sense of self-worth makes a positive connotation
for self-love appealing. But self-worth, like self-respect, is
best secured through loving others and graciously receiving love
from others. Believing that we have love for others validates
our sense of being loveable. This allows us to let love in. Feeling
good about ourselves and feeling good about others are opposite
sides of the same coin. And having a sense of self-worth develops
our sense of worth for humanity as a whole.
In our attempts to restore self-respect and self-worth, there
is no need to wipe out the age-long distinction that contrasts
love and self-love. Love is the greatest. It is the greatest thing
we can give and the greatest thing we can receive. Self-love has
become a double-edged sword. While the fore edge is being used
to cut away self-deprecation, the back swing carves out a place
for egocentrism.
Love is supposed to be what makes the world go 'round. If we
keep aggrandizing self-love, this world is going to start spinning
in the wrong direction. Words certainly need to have flexible
and evolving definitions. Giving self-love a positive connotation,
however, is pretty ugly, and we should not be terribly pleased
about this. An exact estimate of how much damage has been done
is anybody's guess to calculate. But we shouldn't need to reach
for a pair of plastic glasses to see that we're beyond the definite
maybe stage: self-love is a dangerous oxymoron.
Back
to Articles
Insights Out Publishing
P.O. Box 11286
Boulder, CO 80301 |
halbert@halbertcicles.com
(877) hkatzen toll free phone
(877) 452-8936 |
|